confusions informing Secular Buddhism: technology and ideology

Glenn Wallis’ new book, A Critique of Western Buddhism: Ruins of the Buddhist Real, is getting some well-deserved attention. See the unedited version of the interview from Lion’s Road here, and the review on McConnell’s Post-Traditional Buddhism here.

While I’m creeping forward toward a full review of the book, one aspect of the LR review deserves special attention as it evidences a continuing and fundamental confusion informing Secular Buddhism (to highlight the doctrinal commitments concealed by the seemingly innocuous “secular Buddhism” which makes those commitments normal, normative and invisible). The foundational confusion is the idea that technology can be separate from ideology, that is, from systemic ways of thinking about things and the values motivating actions within such systems of thought. At one point Randy Rosenthal, the Lion’s Roar interviewer, asks:

RR: I’m not sure what a non-buddhism would be in practice. Would it simply be meditating itself, without the “Buddhism”? Basically, I would take a step back and ask if mindfulness practice or vipassana, which I see as secular Buddhism, is helping people “be sane in an insane world,” as you write, or helping say, ADHD affected children function better, then what is better than that? If it’s working—as you do say, it does work—then what’s the problem?

First, to clear the ground: the issue is not whether meditation is “helping people” or not. That is a consistent red herring that regularly deflects attention from the ideological commitments of Secular Buddhism.

Second, the main point of contention: there is no “meditating itself.” Meditation is conducted (meaning both individual practice and social instruction) either in the ideological context of Buddhist praxis, or in the ideological context of a secular, therapeutic culture. The idea that technology and ideology are autonomous is part of the mystification that enables that culture to obscure the naturalizing of contingent views regarding personal identity, societal values, and socio-economic structures. Implicitly normative because they are taken as natural and therefore unproblematic, these contingent views are accepted without reflection and become self-enforcing.

The societal basis for this mystification is very broad, indeed. The disjunction between technology and ideology is pervasive–meditation is no more autonomous in relation to a system of ideological commitments than are cell phones, credit cards, automobiles.

2 thoughts on “confusions informing Secular Buddhism: technology and ideology

  1. This is an interesting discussion. Some relatively recent articles have come out about some Christians expressing serious concerns and outright objections to mindfulness being taught and “indoctrinated” in public schools. While proponents of mindfulness make the claim that it is an entirely secular exercise, I completely empathize why some groups would find it objectionable and think that schools should be taking these concerns more seriously. However, I have had difficulty expressing why this is the case.

    • Their argument is that 1. meditation is Buddhist, 2. Buddhism is a religion, and that therefore to teach meditation is to teach religion–which is either a. legally prohibited, or b. objectionable to members of a Christian culture–Buddhism being subversive to that culture. This of course brings in all the fundamentally racist White, Western Culture triumphalism of the conservative establishment. On this issue Steve Bannon, and Donald Trump demonstrate a coherence with the likes of New York times columnist Ross Douthat.
      For an extended discussion of this topic see Candy Gunther Brown, Debating Yoga and Mindfulness in Public Schools (forthcoming).
      She has also published informative columns on Huffington Post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s